UD Seal

Inclusion. The blog for the Center for Disability Studies.

Trump missed mark on autism

By Victor Schaffner

Share

Donald Trump

Much of America was asleep when, toward the end of the GOP presidential debate Wednesday night, Donald Trump made – as if he were asleep – a connection between vaccines and autism.

As evidence of the connection, he spoke of a two-year-old child who, after getting a vaccine, came down with a fever and “now is autistic.”

Trump then said that by administering vaccines “over a longer period of time … in little sections … I think you’re going to see a big impact on autism.”

One could simply lump Trump’s rant about something he seemed to know nothing about together with utterances from other candidates who feel compelled to take on science-based topics they don’t understand or have failed to appreciate. Fellow presidential aspirant Marco Rubio did so during the same debate when he railed against doing anything of significance to fight climate change.

Doing so could make America “a harder place to live” while doing “nothing – nothing – to change our climate,” he said, even though Rubio, representing Florida in the Senate, should know better. Doing nothing of consequence to fight climate change could make parts of Florida uninhabitable, according to studies that note its vulnerability to devastating sea-level rise, caused by climate change.

One could also hope that a child won’t die or otherwise fall victim to a serious condition that vaccinations are designed to prevent, a not-impossible-to-imagine consequence of a parent following Trump’s go-slow advice on vaccines, predicated on what he suggested in the debate are their connection to autism.

Or one could, and should, go a step further and urge the other candidates in the race – along with public health officials – to take this opportunity to clearly and aggressively debunk the vaccines-contribute-to-autism myth.

Candidate Ben Carson did, but both he and fellow candidate Rand Paul did nothing to debunk the additional go-slow advice on vaccines that Trump advocated. None of the other debaters – and there were eight of them – showed an interest in approaching the issue.

But why? It is a myth that vaccines cause autism.

The nation’s most respected public health centers know it’s a myth, as do its esteemed research hospitals. At its website, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, citing recent research, says “vaccines do not cause autism” and “vaccine ingredients do not cause autism.” At its website, the Mayo Clinic declares “Vaccines do not cause autism,” and adds that the original study that ignited the debate about autism and vaccines has been retracted.

That study, published in 1998 by The Lancet, linked the measles, mumps and rubella vaccine to autism – though it was later discovered that the study’s lead researcher had been compensated for his work by a law firm wishing to sue the makers of the vaccine.

Perhaps these inconvenient truths will do little to stop Trump from spreading the vaccines-autism myth. Perhaps they will do little to keep him from telling his anecdote about the two-year-old child who, after getting a vaccine, came down with a fever and “now is autistic.”

But here at least, Trump doesn’t get the last word. I’ll leave that to the Mayo Clinic, at its website: “Although signs of autism may appear at about the same time children receive certain vaccines – such as the measles, mumps and rubella (MMR) vaccine – this is simply a coincidence.”

About the Author

A longtime journalist, advocate and policy analyst, Victor Schaffner joined UD’s Center for Disabilities Studies as its director of communications and advocacy in 2013. Victor launched the Inclusion blog to engage the disability community, public and policy makers in a provocative discussion of issues with the potential to bring about positive changes in the lives of people with disabilities.

Read full author bio

Comments

  • I believe Mr. Trump decided he would make controversial comments to just get attention. Everyone has an opinion about issues. Sen. Paul and Dr. Carson did not have much time to expand why they believe the vaccines should be given slower. I would suggest that a better forum to ask questions would be in interview instead of debates.
    The moderator of the debate failed to challenge Mr. Trump. The moderator did not challenge him on anything as he was biased toward him as he told him earlier in the day he was a great interview. Finally, the question is, how would the candidates control the CDC and Surgeon General on this type of issue. Wouldthey follow the experts or choose to do whatever they please?

    • Donald Trump certainly relishes controversy, as you note, David. But I don’t know if his comment connecting autism and vaccines was simply evidence of his interest in stirring controversy, which of course begets publicity. It may have simply been an example of his ignorance of an important health issue, and his inability to keep his opinion tied to that ignorance to himself. You also raise an important, critical issue: whether a candidate, once elected, would follow the expertise of the CDC or voice his or her own poorly formed or biased opinion on any number of public health issues. Let’s hope for the former scenario and not the latter.

  • Thank you, thank you. I reposted this on my FB page with an intro that indicates that I did so, not as any political commentary or attack. To do so just takes a discussion of Science and health and turns it into a topic on which “politicians can take a position”. I realize it is your prerogative to do that and you have. I am just glad you have surrounded the politics with an explanation of the science that people can understand and relate to. I hope my introduction to my posting of your blog does the same.

    • Thanks for reading the post and sharing it with your Facebook friends, Vincent. Glad you’re eying and considering what we’re writing about at our new blog.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Center for Disabilities Studies • University of Delaware
461 Wyoming Road • Newark, DE 19716 • USA
Phone: 302-831-6974 • TDD: 302-831-4689